Customer Reviews
Average Customer Review
(10 customer reviews) 22 of 22 people found the following review helpful
A wonderful interpretation of the genius of Brecht and Weill,
March 9, 2001 Linda LeBoutillier "lindaleb" (Eagle, PA United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Weill: The Threepenny Opera (Audio CD)
I own both this version and the Bruckner version of the Three Penny Opera. They are both great in their own right, and I love them both. I this version, Ute Lemper is wonderful! She has a masterful interpretation of Weill's and Brecht's vision, and I have gone on to purchase other works by her. This version definitely is more sophisticated instrumentally. The union of Brecht as a revolutionary writer and Weill as a revolutionary composer was so momentous, and what they produced together so little, that I want to own every version of what they did together. I performed in a Brecht play, the Caucasian Chalk Circle, directed by a famous (then) East German director who was permitted to come to America then. Not one song was memorable. That dinamic of Weill and Brecht was not there. They truly made history in their few works together.If you want to know about their dinamic, this version of The Three Penny Opera will give it to you. This version has many more dialogue links between...Read more
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful
Possibly the definitive recording,
November 23, 2000 Kelly Martino (Austin, TX USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Weill: The Threepenny Opera (Audio CD)
I purchased my first Weill recordings in 1960, the off-broadway Threepenny Opera, and Lenya's Berlin Theater Songs. I have treasured them all my life. Lenya was, of course, incomparable, but Ute Lemper carries on her special genius. This new recording is as near a perfect realization of this unique masterpiece. John Mauceri gives the unique orchestration nuance that even Klemperer missed in his masterful Kleine Dreigroschenmusik. Every member of the cast, even the bit roles, is perfect in the characterization. Kollo is the first performer since Harald Paulsen (the origninal Mackie Messer) to bring all of the tradition of Viennese operetta to this music. He is a miracle. Macheath has subtle characteriztion hitherto unknown except from Paulsen. Most noteworthy is the Jenny of Milva. Two delightful bonuses in the recording: a reprise in Act 2 of Seerauber Jenny by Milva (the Jenny) and the inclusion of Lucy Brown's aria after the Jealousy duet. There is brief dialog before most pieces...Read more
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful
Worth having, even if you prefer the "traditional" rendition,
February 15, 2000 By A Customer
This review is from: Weill: The Threepenny Opera (Audio CD)
I have both this version and Brückner-Rüggeberg's 1958 version. Really, both are worth listening to. This version has, of course, much better sound quality and all the performers are notably better singers. This version was the first one I listened to (over and over again, in point of fact). Basically this recording confirms that, whether Brecht/Weill intended it or not, they created one of the best "muscials" of all time. The songs are very memorable and catchy. Even though I don't know German, they run through my head more readily than, say, the tunes from Cats. (I'm sure that Brecht/Weill are now rolling over in their respective graves :-)When I first heard the older recording, I disliked it due to the seemingly lower quality. However, if you give it a chance, it really begins to grow on you. It was being performed as it was meant to be and the coarser quality fits the mood of all the songs well.