Customer Reviews
Average Customer Review
(115 customer reviews) 21 of 22 people found the following review helpful
A Great CD... Depending On What You're Looking For,
March 26, 1999 M. Yee (Caifornia, United States) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Elton John And Tim Rice's Aida (1999 Concept Album) (Audio CD)
I have to be honest... I bought this CD with the high hopes that it might come across more as a *cast album* that just happens to feature popular artists, as opposed to a soundtrack-ish hodgepodge of musical artists performing songs. While--to my personal disappointment--it was more the latter than the former, I have to give much credit to the CD as an album. Great Elton John songs are captured on the disc with an impressive list of pop genre performers (including Sting, Janet Jackson, James Taylor, and Boyz II Men) and a couple of singers from the actual stage show run (Heather Headley and Sherie Scott).My main gripes have to do with my wish for an actual cast recording. While I knew that this wasn't going to be anything near a cast recording, I still hoped it wouldn't come across too "pop-ish". So, if you're like me and prefer pure Cast Recordings, you might want to wait until the cast recording is actually released. But if you're curious about the...Read more
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful
For What It's Worth,
March 24, 2000 Mark S. (Chicago, Illinois) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Elton John And Tim Rice's Aida (1999 Concept Album) (Audio CD)
I've seen Aida in its try-out period in Chicago, twice. I love the show and had to have the music. However, this concept CD is nothing like the music heard in the show. I enjoy the CD because it is the only way I can hear the music, but I can't wait for the cast soundtrack to come out. If I hadn't seen the show I probably would like the CD better than I do.
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful
What show were you watching Alan?,
March 20, 2000 Mark (New York) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Elton John And Tim Rice's Aida (1999 Concept Album) (Audio CD)
I hope to not turn this into a dueling reviews page, but I too saw the March 16 preview of AIDA on Broadway and cannot fathom Alan's response, particularly in light of the overwhelming audience response to the passion and power of the performers. The music for the stage version is significantly stronger than this album, but I feel that comparing live theater and a concept album is a ridiculous endeavor. If this brings more people to the theater and gets more people interested in Aida, more power to it! I have never witnessed the cheering and ovation I saw during this performance. The cast album is expected in June. I would wait for that to get a true feel for the power of Heather Hedley, Adam Pascal and Cherie Rene Scott.