Customer Reviews
Average Customer Review
(17 customer reviews) 48 of 49 people found the following review helpful
A STELLAR CYCLE, available once again!,
March 18, 2011 Gregory E. Foster "operabruin" (Portland, ME, USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Beethoven: Complete Piano Sonatas & Concertos (Audio CD)
YES!
This is the cycle IMHO that put Alfred Brendel "on the map" for Beethoven interpretation. How well I remember the day I purchased this set on LP, in the BIG BOX, and literally "danced" out of the store, went home and began listening to these recordings for the first time! First, I had never heard all of the sonatas until then, and second I was simply in awe of the magnitude of this great volume of work written by perhaps the greatest musical genious of all time. I was mesmerized and this set (minus the concertos, of course) quickly became one of my most treasured recordings. Somehow, sadly, I missed this release the first time 'round on cd but did buy the digitally recorded traversal (his third set), but while they were quite wonderful I felt them not of the same character overall as this middle set of recordings, and longed for them but was not willing to pay collector prices for them.
How fortuitous for us that Decca (somehow the successor? of Philips) has...Read more
25 of 27 people found the following review helpful
The Beethoven set I have been waiting for.,
February 22, 2011 Mahler fan (Georgia, USA) - See all my reviews
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Beethoven: Complete Piano Sonatas & Concertos (Audio CD)
I have admired this set of Beethoven's piano sonatas for many years, but I've never purchased it until now. Brendel's first and last complete cycles leave me a bit cold, whereas this middle cycle from the 1970s is consistently captivating, especially in some of the less popular works. His performance of the second mvt. of Op. 54 is worth the price of the entire box! Pianists in my opinion usually get Op. 54 wrong, playing the finale much too fast or too dry (e.g. Frank or Ashkenazy). Brendel's pacing is perfect, and his pedaling is sublime. Speaking of pedaling, he also gets the Waldstein finale just right: wonderfully blurry at the beginning, but with subtle pedal changes that keep the texture from becoming a catatonic mess. The op. 2 sonatas are also a joy. While this box may lack the fire of Ashkenazy and Claude Frank (both of whose complete Beethoven sets I love), it contains genuine poetry, and I would recommend it without qualification. I've only listened to the 3rd...Read more
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful
Looking for a Good First Set of Beethoven's Piano Sonatas? Look No Further ...,
December 13, 2011 Ray "A Reader" - See all my reviews
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Beethoven: Complete Piano Sonatas & Concertos (Audio CD)
There's no denying that Alfred Brendel is one of the most esteemed pianists of the past half century, and Beethoven was among his particular specialties. Brendel actually recorded the complete set of 32 Beethoven Piano Sonatas three times during his career (he retired from public performances in 2008), and due to his expertise and command of the piano, as well as his interpretive skill of Beethoven's works, won acclaim for each of these cycles. As with many "best of kind" performances, these sets could, unfortunately, be hideously expensive to acquire, but if one had the opportunity to enjoy them, the rewards were substantial. There's a reason why Brendel has racked up so many awards and has been received with such universal acclaim, and even the briefest of examinations of any of these recording sets reveals just why.
Brendel has a magnificent command of the instrument. It is difficult to describe his style, but I might suggest that he is a classicist in performance,...Read more